Anthropology vs History. Which is better optional for UPSC CSE
Anthropology vs History: Which Optional is Better for UPSC?
The selection of an optional subject for the UPSC Civil Services Examination plays a crucial role in your success. With multiple choices available, two popular options often considered by aspirants are Anthropology and History. Each has its own set of benefits and challenges. This blog aims to offer an in-depth comparison of both subjects to help you make an informed decision.
Understanding the Nature of the Subjects
Anthropology
Anthropology is the scientific study of human evolution, society, and cultures. It includes physical anthropology, social anthropology, and archaeology. One of the primary reasons for its popularity is its concise syllabus and a blend of scientific and social science elements.
History
History covers ancient, medieval, and modern Indian and world history. It demands a good memory for facts, timelines, and events and a deeper understanding of socio-political movements over centuries.
Syllabus Comparison
Anthropology has a relatively short and manageable syllabus. Many topics can be completed in less time compared to other optionals. There is also a lot of overlap with GS Paper I (Indian Society) and GS Paper IV (Ethics).
History, on the other hand, has a vast syllabus and requires in-depth knowledge of different eras and interpretations. However, it has a considerable overlap with GS Paper I and the Essay paper.
Scoring Trend
According to recent UPSC trends, Anthropology has been a consistent scoring optional. Many toppers, including candidates ranked in the top 100, have opted for Anthropology due to its high success ratio.
History has had mixed results in terms of marks. Due to its vastness, some aspirants struggle to complete the syllabus on time, which might affect performance.
Availability of Resources
Both subjects have decent study material and coaching support available. However, Anthropology might have fewer resources compared to History, but this gap is narrowing due to online platforms.
Ease of Understanding
Anthropology is easier to grasp, especially for students with a science background. Its objective approach helps in clear understanding and logical answering.
History can be complex due to its subjective nature and multiple interpretations of the same event. However, it is interesting for those who enjoy stories and patterns of the past.
Expert Mentorship
Guidance plays a key role in mastering any optional. For Anthropology, experts like Dr. Huma Hassan (Plutus IAS) have been consistently producing excellent results. For History, mentors like Mohit Kumar Lathar are widely trusted.
👉 Explore our UPSC mentorship program
Success Ratio
Data from recent years indicate that Anthropology has had a higher success ratio among aspirants with non-history backgrounds. Its limited syllabus and scoring nature make it a safer bet for many candidates.
What UPSC Says?
According to the official notification from UPSC’s official website, both Anthropology and History are available as optional subjects, and the choice should be based on the aspirant’s interest and background.
Final Verdict: Which is Better?
There is no one-size-fits-all answer. If you are from a science background or prefer concise and scoring subjects, Anthropology could be the right choice. If you love reading historical events and already have a humanities background, History might suit you better.
Still confused? Get expert guidance at TheHinduZone or compare top mentor ratings at
Internal Resources
Conclusion
The decision between Anthropology and History should depend on your personal interest, academic background, and comfort with the syllabus. Remember, the right optional is the one you can master with confidence and consistency. Focus on consistent revision, answer writing, and expert guidance to maximize your success in the UPSC exam.
« Anthropology vs Public Administration : Which Optional is Better?
